高討論度手機拍照評比:HTC U11+ vs Apple iPhone XR vs R17

2019.01.23 08:00AM
91705
Photography, Girl, girl, girl, photography, eye, smile, brown hair, grass

近期智慧型手機拍照性能越來越好,已經成為許多人外出記錄生活的首選。在諸多頂級旗艦智慧型手機之外,有沒有其他拍照優秀,價格又在可以接受的機種呢?

所以我們這回選了三支手機,包含近期降價,拍照頗受好評的前代旗艦HTC U11+Apple目前最新機種,比較迎向大眾的iPhone XR、以合宜價格切入中階市場的OPPO R17

現在,我們來看看這幾支手機的表現吧!


目錄


 

一、基礎表現:色彩、細節與夜拍

我們在測試這天,是個多雲時晴的好天氣,色彩部分我們拍了三組照片。

從第一組照片來說,三支手機各自有各自的特色,以iPhone XR來說,是屬於比較偏暖偏黃的顏色調性;HTC U11+則居中,在顏色傾向是比較準確且舒服的色調;OPPO R17則略微偏冷,畫面也略微偏白。

Jeans, Denim, Dress, Skirt, Outerwear, Shoe, Shoulder, Pattern, shoulder, clothing, shoulder, sitting, denim, jeans, outerwear, dress, girl, pattern, shoe

▲Apple iPhone XR

Jeans, Denim, Skirt, Outerwear, Shoulder, Pattern, denim, clothing, denim, shoulder, jeans, outerwear, girl, pattern, trunk, trousers

▲HTC U11+

Jeans, Denim, Shoe, Skirt, Outerwear, Pattern, Shoulder, shoulder, clothing, shoulder, denim, sitting, jeans, outerwear, girl, pattern, design, trousers

▲OPPO R17

在第二組照片來說,三支手機大致上的顏色傾向是跟第一組相同的。在這個場景來說,顏色略多一些,大致上也可以看出各支手機的準確性。

以還原現場的顏色,還有販賣機本身的油漆外觀質感來說,表現比較好的是HTC U11+;而iPhone XR顏色飽和但略微偏黃;OPPO R17整體則是偏淡、偏亮,畫面顏色略微平一些。

Vending Machines, vending machine, vending machine, machine

▲Apple iPhone XR

Vending Machines, vending machine, vending machine, machine

▲HTC U11+

Vending Machines, vending machine, vending machine, machine

▲OPPO R17

 

在第三組照片來說,差異是最明顯的,iPhone XR與HTC U11+本身在石牆的質感、顏色呈現比較正確,U11+本身最接近現場的顏色,Model本身的膚色也成現有氣色而不偏黃的狀況。

而OPPO R17略帶橙色的牆面在這邊變成黃色,表現出來的顏色差異較大。

Photograph, /m/083vt, , Photograph, Photograph, photograph, photograph, wall, standing, wood, girl, window, door

▲Apple iPhone XR

Door, Outerwear, Pattern, standing, standing, girl, wall, outerwear, pattern, door

▲HTC U11+

wall, wall, standing, girl

▲OPPO R17

 

日間拍攝的部分,剛好在途中遇到了幾隻貓咪。

這組照片中,我們可以放大來檢視貓咪毛髮與背景細小葉子的細節。這組照片來說,同樣由HTC U11+與iPhone XR帶來比較銳利且細節豐富的觀看感,而OPPO R17比起前二者略微糊些。

Whiskers, Cat, , Fauna, grass, cat, fauna, small to medium sized cats, cat like mammal, grass, whiskers, wildlife, tail

▲Apple iPhone XR

Whiskers, Cat, , Fauna, grass, cat, fauna, small to medium sized cats, cat like mammal, grass, whiskers, tail, wildlife

▲HTC U11+

Whiskers, Cat, , Fauna, wildlife, cat, fauna, small to medium sized cats, cat like mammal, wildlife, grass, whiskers, tail

▲OPPO R17

 

我們接著來看關於一般夜晚的拍攝。一般在夜拍來說,比較考驗到手機對於拉高感光度的處理,包含抑制雜訊與維持銳利度。

這組照片來說,三支手機在畫質與顏色調性仍舊略有差異。以多重光源的白平衡表現來看,HTC U11+觀看的感覺較舒適、銳利度也略好,而OPPO R17在畫面的乾淨程度表現較好。

House, Light, Sky, alley, town, alley, street, infrastructure, road, light, night, city, neighbourhood, evening

▲Apple iPhone XR

Sky, alley, town, street, alley, night, city, road, evening, sky, darkness, facade

▲HTC U11+

House, Sky, alley, town, street, alley, infrastructure, night, light, sky, road, evening, city

▲OPPO R17

 

二、人像表現

 

在看完顏色與一般日夜拍的表現後,我們來看看三支手機在人像拍攝的表現。在這邊我們拍攝了:一般人像拍照、人像模式(散景模擬)與自拍的照片。

Cellular network, Girl, Mobile Phones, iPhone, girl, electronic device, technology, gadget, girl, hand, communication device, mobile phone, cellular network

從剛剛以來,Apple iPhone XR本身偏黃的傾向是很明顯的。而以HTC U11+來說,它的顏色傾向不管是從一般風景或者是人像都是一致的:討喜而不過度飽和,這點可以從Model臉頰的腮紅與膚色看出。

OPPO R17本身則是偏冷偏亮的調性,在人像照片來說,膚色呈現比較白晰的狀況。

Cherry blossom, ST.AU.150 MIN.V.UNC.NR AD, Portrait, Girl, Portrait photographer, Photography, Blossom, Cherries, Blossom, Leaf, nature, nature, tree, flower, plant, woody plant, beauty, girl, leaf, autumn, spring

▲Apple iPhone XR

Cherry blossom, Portrait, Portrait photographer, ST.AU.150 MIN.V.UNC.NR AD, Photography, Cherries, Girl, Leaf, Lady M Confections Co., LTD, Blossom, beauty, skin, beauty, woman, girl, tree, woody plant, lady, flower, plant, leaf

▲HTC U11+

Tree, Portrait, Portrait photographer, Photography, Skin, Flower, Leaf, Beauty.m, nature, nature, beauty, skin, girl, tree, woody plant, flower, plant, lady, leaf

▲OPPO R17

 

而在人像模式(景深模擬)的場景來看。iPhons Xr雖然只有單鏡頭,只要能辨識出人臉,一就可以模擬出背景模糊的淺景深效果;OPPO R17則受益於雙鏡頭,也能模擬出淺景深的部分。

HTC U11+目前沒有獨立的人像模式,我們則以後鏡頭直接拍攝。整體看來,iPhons Xr略黃,HTC U11+擁有三者中比較好的色彩準確與人臉氣色。

OPPO R17的人像模式跟先前直接拍攝的調性有些不同,雖然一樣是偏亮偏白,但是對比又更下降,整體亮度也更提高,也會是相當討女性喜愛的傾向。

Blazer, Fashion, Trench coat, Girl, Socialite, Coat, girl, clothing, coat, girl, snapshot, outerwear, shoulder, fashion, blazer, long hair, jacket

▲Apple iPhone XR

SPOT Huashan cinema, Accupass活動通辦公室, One Town One Product, Starfield Coex Mall, , , Cinema, Event Tickets, , Entertainment, SPOT Huashan cinema, shoulder, snapshot, handbag, coat, outerwear, girl, bag

▲HTC U11+

Huashan 1914 Creative Park, 桦山町, SPOT Huashan cinema, , 大竹囲, Tourist attraction, Japan, , Restaurant, Food, Huashan 1914 Creative Park, clothing, coat, snapshot, outerwear, girl, shoulder, fashion model, long hair

▲OPPO R17

 

在自拍來說,iPhone Xr本身沒有提供美顏的選項可以使用;HTC U11+、OPPO R17則都可以讓使用者自行選擇美顏模式的開啟與否。

以前鏡頭來說,iPhone XR一樣偏暖偏黃,HTC U11+略帶洋紅,OPPO R17則跟後鏡頭傾向不同,顏色討喜些。

以前鏡頭的自拍來看,HTC U11+與OPPO R17是比較符合大眾口味的。

另外在前鏡頭的人像模式(景深模擬),iPhone XR與OPPO R17都能夠有淺景深模擬的效果,HTC U11+只有一般的自拍模式。

Hair coloring, Hair, Blond, Brown hair, Girl, Long hair, 02PD - Circolo del Partito Democratico di Milano, Brown, Beauty.m, girl, facial expression, girl, human hair color, beauty, hairstyle, snapshot, smile, long hair, hair coloring, brown hair

▲Apple iPhone XR:前鏡頭自拍

Hair, Long hair, Hair coloring, Bangs, 02PD - Circolo del Partito Democratico di Milano, Beauty.m, beauty, skin, beauty, girl, lady, hairstyle, snapshot, eye, smile, cheek, long hair

▲Apple iPhone XR:前鏡頭自拍人像模式

Hair coloring, Hair, 02PD - Circolo del Partito Democratico di Milano, girl, skin, girl, hairstyle, snapshot, smile, long hair, hair coloring, product, fun, brown hair

▲HTC U11+:前鏡頭自拍

Hair coloring, Hair, Long hair, Bangs, 02PD - Circolo del Partito Democratico di Milano, Beauty.m, girl, skin, girl, beauty, hairstyle, snapshot, long hair, hair coloring, smile, brown hair, japanese idol

▲OPPO R17:前鏡頭自拍

Long hair, Hair coloring, Black hair, Hair, Brown hair, Bangs, Black, Brown, 02PD - Circolo del Partito Democratico di Milano, Beauty.m, girl, hair, human hair color, hairstyle, girl, beauty, snapshot, long hair, hair coloring, bangs, black hair

▲OPPO R17:前鏡頭自拍人像模式

 

三、高反差場景:HDR

 

隨著技術的進步,HDR也成為手機中拍照一個很重要且便利的功能。在逆光與高反差的場景,它能讓我們拍攝的照片成果更理想。

第一個HDR的場景來看,是一個正對太陽的大逆光。在這三支手機拍攝的HDR開關照片來看,都有相當顯著的幫助:可以讓逆光過暗的部分增亮,也能讓過亮的部分減低程度。

Urban area, , Metropolitan area, Lawn, Stichting Metropolis M., Suburb, High-rise building, Condominium, Tree, Sky, sky, sky, urban area, skyline, metropolitan area, skyscraper, daytime, city, landmark, cloud, cityscape

▲Apple iPhone XR:HDR關

Urban area, , Metropolitan area, Lawn, Suburb, Stichting Metropolis M., High-rise building, Tree, Condominium, Sky, sky, sky, urban area, metropolitan area, skyline, skyscraper, daytime, city, landmark, cloud, grass

▲Apple iPhone XR:HDR開

Urban area, , Metropolitan area, Lawn, Suburb, Stichting Metropolis M., High-rise building, Tree, Sky, Tower Block, sky, sky, urban area, daytime, cloud, metropolitan area, city, skyline, skyscraper, grass, tree

▲HTC U11+:HDR關

Urban area, , Meter, Metropolitan area, Square meter, Tower Block, Road surface, Lawn, Suburb, Stichting Metropolis M., sky, sky, urban area, metropolitan area, daytime, skyline, city, landmark, skyscraper, grass, tree

▲HTC U11+:HDR開

Metropolitan area, Infrastructure, , Urban area, Tower, High-rise building, Suburb, Stichting Metropolis M., Plaza M, Condominium, sky, sky, metropolitan area, urban area, skyscraper, skyline, daytime, city, landmark, cloud, infrastructure

▲OPPO R17:HDR關

Metropolitan area, , Meter, Square meter, Tower Block, Urban area, Stichting Metropolis M., Suburb, Plaza M, Corporation, metropolitan area, metropolitan area, sky, urban area, skyscraper, city, skyline, daytime, landmark, tower block, cloud

▲OPPO R17:HDR開

 

而以逆光人像的部分,三支手機各有不同的表現。

iPhone XR HDR開關與否,牽扯到的是極亮處的細節保留,照片畫面上方的建築物,HDR開啟與關閉與否差異就相當明顯。

HTC U11+部分,顏色依舊是討人喜歡的,在畫面上方建築物的細節保留較不明顯,但是Model背後的灰白色牆面,當開啟HDR時細節保留比較明顯。

OPPO R17在逆光人像是否開啟HDR,效果有比較明顯的變化。開啟HDR時,在照片畫面上方的建築物細節有保留下來,但是以人像膚色來說,關閉HDR的膚色比較讓人喜歡。

Street, Road surface, Sidewalk, House, Asphalt, Road, Tree, Laborer, Bricklayer, wall, wall, tree, road, house, asphalt, roof, brickwork, street, brick, facade

▲Apple iPhone XR:HDR關

Street, House, Sidewalk, Tree, wall, wall, tree, road, house, street, sidewalk, facade, roof

▲Apple iPhone XR:HDR開

Street, House, Sidewalk, Girl, Tree, street, road, street, girl, tree, house, recreation, sidewalk

▲HTC U11+:HDR關

Outerwear, Jeans, Denim, Dress, Girl, Tree, Pattern, girl, clothing, road, infrastructure, girl, outerwear, dress, street, tree, jeans, denim

▲HTC U11+:HDR開

Street, House, Sidewalk, Tree, Girl, house, house, tree, road, street, sidewalk, window, girl, facade

▲OPPO R17:HDR關

House, Tree, house, house, town, wall, tree, street, road, alley, window, facade, sidewalk

▲OPPO R17:HDR開

 

四、以手機挑戰更不同的夜景:M Mode 手動拍攝模式

 

對攝影愛好者來說,能自由的控制各種選項,像是白平衡、感光度、光圈、快門、對焦等等,是再好不過的了。

我們也針對這個部分來做個介紹。

Desktop Wallpaper, Graphics, Multimedia, Display device, Computer, Computer Monitors, Gadget, Brand, multimedia, multimedia, gadget, display device, technology, computer wallpaper, night, screenshot, darkness, font, brand

如果我們能夠有較長的曝光時間,以都市的夜景來說,就有機會讓車流拉出光軌。

三支手機中,iPhone XR內建的相機APP中,沒有提供任何可以手動調整的選項,因此在夜晚拍攝的話,比較難達成流動的光軌照片。

National Chiang Kai-shek Memorial Hall, , Midnight Memories, Desktop Wallpaper, Screenshot, Computer, Visual Effects, Night, Sky, chiang kai-shek memorial hall, atmosphere, sky, screenshot, darkness, night, midnight, computer wallpaper, font

HTC U11+與OPPO R17皆有M Mode的模式可以調整許多參數,都可以利用長時間曝光來拍攝這些題材。

OPPO R17可支援16秒的長時間曝光,HTC U11+則更進一步支援到32秒,只要有穩定的腳架,拍攝星空也不成問題。

National Chiang Kai-shek Memorial Hall, Town square, Tourist attraction, M-05, Street light, Street, Arhitektūras piemineklis, Downtown, Tourism, Facade pattern, chiang kai-shek memorial hall, landmark, night, architecture, light, city, tourist attraction, sky, lighting, evening, town square

▲Apple iPhone XR

National Chiang Kai-shek Memorial Hall, Facade, Tourist attraction, Architecture, M-05, Arhitektūras piemineklis, Facade pattern, Downtown, Tourism, Town Square Las Vegas, chiang kai-shek memorial hall, night, landmark, city, light, architecture, lighting, evening, tourist attraction, town square, downtown

▲HTC U11+

National Chiang Kai-shek Memorial Hall, Tourist attraction, Facade, Street, , Street light, Tourism, Stichting Metropolis M., Square meter, Plaza M, chiang kai-shek memorial hall, night, landmark, city, light, architecture, lighting, sky, town square, evening, tourist attraction

▲OPPO R17

 

然而支援長時間曝光也有其他更進一步的用途。

比方說像是夜晚的中正紀念堂,由於燈光相當昏暗,因此直接拍攝的話手機將會拉高ISO感光度,畫面上躁點顆粒都會比較明顯。

如果又遇到亮度過暗曝光時間無法拉長,也很容易拍下略暗的照片。

如果能夠與M模式支援更長時間的曝光,我們也能使用較長的曝光時間去搭配低感光度,在畫面亮度與畫面的純淨度都達成更好的平衡與成果。

 

Night, Dusk, Lighting, , Midnight Memories, Evening, Tree, Darkness, Stichting Metropolis M., Sky, sky, sky, cloud, night, landmark, architecture, atmosphere, evening, darkness, dusk, lighting

▲Apple iPhone XR

Light, Urban area, Night, Evening, Dusk, Darkness, Tree, Stichting Metropolis M., Square meter, Sky, sky, sky, landmark, cloud, night, town, urban area, light, architecture, evening, dusk

▲HTC U11+

, Night, Dusk, Evening, Lighting, Meter, Square meter, Cloud computing, Sky, sky, sky, landmark, cloud, night, light, architecture, evening, dusk, lighting, city

▲OPPO R17

另外如果你追求更極致的畫質與細部調整的話,HTC U11+也提供了RAW檔格式,保留了最原始的拍攝資訊,在進行調整的時候,也能夠擁有最大的彈性。

HTC Desire Eye, HTC One M9, , HTC One, HTC, HTC Butterfly 3, HTC 10, Android, , Screenshot, chiang kai-shek memorial hall, night, lighting, screenshot, computer wallpaper, recreation, darkness, brand, games, midnight

 

在最後,我們也附加上U11+以長時間曝光來拍攝的夜空,這次的拍照比對當中,U11+與R17都支援了M模式與長時間曝光,但是U11+則以更長的32秒比R17(最長16秒),能夠在極限的昏暗環境下更有拍攝成功的可能性,像是下面就是以U11+所拍攝到的星空照片。

HTC, , HTC U11+, , HTC One, Hehuanshan, Android, Astronomy, OUTER SPACE, Facebook, nature, nature, sky, night, atmosphere, darkness, aurora, star, astronomical object, astronomy, midnight

▲HTC U11+所拍攝的星空照片(HTC論壇使用者wang178所拍攝)

Street light, Street, Mountain, Sky, sky, sky, nature, night, light, lighting, mountain, atmosphere, evening, cloud, dusk

▲HTC U11+所拍攝的星空照片(HTC論壇使用者wang178所拍攝)

 

在測試這幾支手機的時候,我們也進行了錄影相關的使用。在這三支手機中,HTC U11+在錄影時支援了一個「聽覺焦點」的功能,當你在錄影時變焦,錄製的聲音會跟著你的變焦焦點而靠近變大。

提到錄影的聲音表現外,在這三支手機當中,HTC U11+其實也是在聲音的體驗上,用上許多不同的技術。

Graphic design, Desktop Wallpaper, Brand, Computer, Organism, Font, Line, Screenshot, Design, Graphics, high-resolution audio, text, font, line, organism, graphic design, brand, screenshot, computer wallpaper, product, graphics

▲重視個人音效體驗的話,HTC也在各面向提供多方位的優質體驗。上圖為HTC USonic以類聲納的方式根據每個人耳道結構不同所製作音效設定檔

 

如果是一般直接以手機播放聲音的狀態,U11+本身擁有的HTC BoomSound Hifi超聲動音響的技術,它是利用整個手機當作音箱的共振,能發出更大的聲音與失真更少的立體音效。

若是重視個人化的聲音體驗與抗躁效果,U11+也附上了一個支援主動抗躁的HTC USonic耳機,利用類聲納的技術去偵測使用者的耳道結構,進而去提供個人化的聲音體驗。

 

五、結語

綜合上面的實際拍攝,我們也來為幾隻手機進行相關的結語。

Apple iPhone XR本身擁有這代A12處理器的加持,儘管只是單鏡頭,但是不管是HDR效果或者單鏡頭景深模擬效果,都可圈可點。

以預設的相機APP拍攝效果來看,iPhone XR是有其限制的。但iOS龐大的APP軟體支援,不管是拍照APP、濾鏡APP、影像處理APP都有豐沛的資源,這也是iPhone XR其擁有的優勢。

是平價旗艦手機拍照比一比:HTC U11+ vs Apple iPhone XR vs R17這篇文章的第52圖

HTC U11+無疑地是這次測試中的意外驚喜。2017年推出的它,在此時拍照的成品依舊名列前茅,不管是顏色飽和度、準確度與畫質本身的銳利都相當好,加上近期又再次降價3000元,64GB的版本只要12,900元,可說非常超值。

U11+本身支援蠻獨特的Edge Sense操作,經過設定只要擠壓一下就能開啟相機APP,拍攝便利性相當理想。而防水防塵的設計,臨時遇到下雨,也能盡情拍照不受影響。

加上其完整的M模式控制、良好的聲音表現,如果是攝影愛好者與影音愛好者來說,目前12,900元的價格可說是以中階的價格獲得旗艦的表現。

OPPO R17來說,整體以拍照的成品來說是比較偏白、偏冷,某些照片成品會比較平淡。但OPPO本身對於人像與自拍的耕耘自不在話下,如果是對這兩類類型的拍攝有偏好的話,R17這部分的表現也相當值得稱許。

那麼,這回的平價旗艦手機拍照比一比到這裡為止囉!喜歡哪一支手機呢?

Model:五十嵐幸子 Sachiko 撒醬 / 實拍:euyoung's soliloquy

回應 43

43 則回應

熱門文章

最新消息

本日精選